'Players' review: The new Paramount+ series is exactly how you tell a heartfelt esports story

The faux documentary from the 'American Vandal' creators is a master class on telling un-embarrassing stories about games.
By Adam Rosenberg  on 
A still from the Paramount+ series "Players."
The Fugitive Gaming crew, posing for their esports-standard team shot. Credit: Scott McDermott / Paramount+

Players didn't make me cringe once. It would have been so easy for the faux documentary esports series on Paramount+ to lean into a satire of offensive stereotypes. But Players chooses peace over violence, and the result is one of the strongest originals from the streaming service so far.

It helps that the new series comes from American Vandal co-creators Dan Perrault and Tony Yacenda. As fans of the Netflix mockumentary would expect, there are plenty of laughs here. But where Vandal took a serious-minded high school incident and made it a silly story, Players does the opposite: It's a smart and heartfelt character piece that drapes itself in the inherent silliness of adolescent gamers who got too much money and fame at too young an age.

Creamcheese (Misha Brooks) initially comes off like a juvenile douche. He's an arrogant and boastful League of Legends pro who, we quickly learn, hasn't ever managed to actually bring a championship home with his team, Fugitive Gaming. But he's also lived that familiar real-world esports success story of having his team acquired by a major business figure in legacy pro sports.

So while Creamcheese may not be an actual winner, he talks and carries himself like one. That unearned chutzpah is challenged when Nathan Resnick (Stephen Schneider), the NBA team owner who also pays Fugitive's bills, privately courts an emerging League phenom who calls himself Organizm (Da'Jour Jones).

A still from the Paramount+ series "Players"
Da'Jour Jones' understated performance as Organizm is an important piece of his arc across the 10-episode season. Credit: Lara Solanki / Paramount+

The quiet and withdrawn 17-year-old from Philadelphia is quickly signed to Fugitive's roster, and Nathan forces team coach and co-founder Kyle Braxton (Ely Henry) into forgoing training and making Org an immediate starter on the team. Cream is incensed by the move, which sets up an early conflict between the two pros that twists and evolves as Players' 10 episodes unfurl.

In the earliest episodes, it does feel like Perrault and Yacenda are serving viewers a video game-themed take on "Who did the dicks?" When we hear about how Org used to pee in jars at home so he could keep playing, or the time when Cream stole his lucky keyboard back from his unsupportive parents' house, the writing sprints right up to the razor's edge of hyperbolic stereotyping.

It's all part of a larger plan, though. The story even shows its hand briefly in the first episode, when Cream gets emotional as he talks about how his parents filed a police report over the missing keyboard. When we return to that scene later with more knowledge of the characters, it just hits different. Players understands how gamers as a group tend to get pigeonholed as "losers," and it's not taking any of that shit.

Again and again, the series undermines its own big laugh moments by feeding us historical context that re-frames those moments in a new light. We learn early on that Cream's original in-game handle was "Nutmilk," and we instantly jump to crude conclusions about its meaning. But the truth is much more innocent, as a later episode reveals.

'Players' chooses peace over violence, and the result is one of the strongest originals from Paramount+ so far.

It's a clever bit of plotting where the delayed torpedoing of expectations maximizes the follow-up moment's emotional impact. Players repeats itself often, with that repetition adding pertinent details to every subplot along the way. The show's writers know how funny gamer antics are in a vacuum, and they let those moments live on the screen for laughs. But the writers also weaponize added context very effectively to get us thinking about what, exactly, we thought was so funny.

That's not to say Players is its own buzzkill. The comedy moments are genuinely funny and the details that bring added depth are presented in a completely nonjudgmental way. You're not supposed to feel bad about laughing. It is some kind of comedy that a committed player would opt for jars over a bathroom toilet just to squeeze a few more minutes of gaming into the day.

What the show does do is remind us that all of these people are just that: complex human beings, with thoughts, feelings, desires, and histories that made them what they are. It's perfectly understandable to laugh at the hyperbolic soundbites or juvenile behavior, but Players contends — rightly, I think — that it's equally important to recognize that even the most dedicated and seemingly ridiculous stereotypical gamer has stuff they carry around.

Family strife. Romantic upheavals. Even health concerns. Relatable struggles all around. Cream, Org, and the rest of Fugitive have known these trials themselves in their own highly personal ways. Cream may come off like an overly arrogant perennial loser up front, but that whole shtick starts to make more sense as Players fills out his history.

A still from the Paramount+ series "Players"
Misha Brooks and Ely Henry make Cream's enduring friendship with Brax feel honest, complex, and deeply loving. Credit: Lara Solanki / Paramount+

None of it would work if not for the cast. Brooks and Jones both inhabit their roles exceptionally well, but they're hardly alone. Henry's turn as Kyle, aka Brax, is a clear standout. Brax is one of Cream's oldest friends, but he's also a married dad who is much more grown up and tuned into the ways of the world. Cream's angry outbursts test Brax regularly, but the love Brax has for his friend carries through clearly in Henry's terrific performance.

The documentary-like structure and blending of fact and fiction also work in the series' favor. Recurring talking head-style interviews create an organic entry point into each major character's worldview and mindset. And by grounding everything in the familiar visuals of Riot Games' esports hit and the League of Legends Championship Series — neither of which you need to know inside-out; Players explains as it goes — the show feels like an authentic representation of modern gaming culture.

The long arc of the season develops into an underdog story characterized by the kinds of twists and turns you'd expect to find in a more traditional sports drama like Rocky or Rudy. But knowing these guys are destined to win one day in some fashion doesn't detract from the journey they take to get there, or the various ways that journey impacts their relationships.

Players wins because of the people. For all their juvenile behavior and youthful vigor-fueled acts of self-sabotage, Fugitive Gaming is an easy crew to root for. The twist is that none of it is a send-up. It's earnest and heartfelt. You're supposed to love these guys. Players' subversion of expectations effectively peels away our surface understandings of games, gamers, and gaming culture to deliver a story that, refreshingly, does right by all three.

Topics Gaming Streaming

Mashable Image
Adam Rosenberg

Adam Rosenberg is a Senior Games Reporter for Mashable, where he plays all the games. Every single one. From AAA blockbusters to indie darlings to mobile favorites and browser-based oddities, he consumes as much as he can, whenever he can.Adam brings more than a decade of experience working in the space to the Mashable Games team. He previously headed up all games coverage at Digital Trends, and prior to that was a long-time, full-time freelancer, writing for a diverse lineup of outlets that includes Rolling Stone, MTV, G4, Joystiq, IGN, Official Xbox Magazine, EGM, 1UP, UGO and others.Born and raised in the beautiful suburbs of New York, Adam has spent his life in and around the city. He's a New York University graduate with a double major in Journalism and Cinema Studios. He's also a certified audio engineer. Currently, Adam resides in Crown Heights with his dog and his partner's two cats. He's a lover of fine food, adorable animals, video games, all things geeky and shiny gadgets.


Recommended For You
How to watch Arizona vs. Dayton basketball livestreams without cable
Kylan Boswell #4 of the Arizona Wildcats controls the ball against Marcus Tsohonis #0 of Long Beach State during the first half in the first round of the NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament at Delta Center on March 21, 2024, in Salt Lake City, Utah.

How to watch Arizona vs. Clemson basketball without cable
Caleb Love #2, Keshad Johnson #16, Oumar Ballo #11, and Jaden Bradley #0 of the Arizona Wildcats look on as Pelle Larsson #3 shoots free throws against the Dayton Flyers during the second half in the second round of the NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament at Delta Center on March 23, 2024, in Salt Lake City, Utah.

How to watch Gonzaga vs. Kansas basketball without cable
Anton Watson #22 of the Gonzaga Bulldogs dunks the ball against the McNeese State Cowboys during the second half in the first round of the NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament at Delta Center on March 21, 2024, in Salt Lake City, Utah.

How to watch Duke vs. James Madison basketball without cable
Shamir Bogues #12 of the Vermont Catamounts defends against Jared McCain #0 of the Duke Blue Devils during the first half in the first round of the NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament at Barclays Center on March 22, 2024, in New York City.

How to watch Marquette vs. Colorado basketball without cable
KJ Simpson #2 of the Colorado Buffaloes celebrates with his teammates after hitting the game-winning shot to defeat the Florida Gators in the first round of the NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament at Gainbridge Fieldhouse on March 22, 2024, in Indianapolis, Indiana.

More in Entertainment

What will happen when the next supervolcano erupts, according to NASA
The view from the International Space Station as the Raikoke volcano erupts in 2019. (Not a super-eruption; such an event hasn't happened in modern history.)

The internet is freaking out about reheated rice. Should you be worried?
A man reheating rice

CERN's Large Hadron Collider is looking for dark photons. But... why?
one of the LHC particle accelerator's tunnels


Trending on Mashable
NYT Connections today: See hints and answers for March 28
A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.'

NYT's The Mini crossword answers for March 28
Closeup view of crossword puzzle clues

Wordle today: Here's the answer and hints for March 28
a phone displaying Wordle

NYT Connections today: See hints and answers for March 27
A phone displaying the New York Times game 'Connections.'

The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox.
This newsletter may contain advertising, deals, or affiliate links. Subscribing to a newsletter indicates your consent to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. You may unsubscribe from the newsletters at any time.
Thanks for signing up. See you at your inbox!